Meet the Authors

Andrew Tedstone

In the field: lead author Andrew Tedstone (University of Edinburgh) on his way to make measurements of the flow of the Greenland Ice Sheet. Photo Credit: Jon Hawkings (University of Bristol)

Peter Nienow

In the field: co-author Peter Nienow (University of Edinburgh) on the Greenland Ice Sheet at ~1950m on the EGIG line (l’Expedition Glaciologique Internationale au Groenland at 69 51N, 47 15W) during the Cal/Val program for the European Space Agency’s CryoSat mission, April 2006. Photo credit: Doug Mair

Noel Gourmelen

In the field: co-author Noel Gourmelen (University of Edinburgh) on the Larsen-C Ice Shelf, Antarctic Peninsula, setting up a wintering GPS station for measuring ice flow and tidal motion. Photo credit: Adam Clark

Amaury Dehecq

In the field: co-author Amaury Dehecq (Université Savoie Mont-Blanc / University of Edinburgh) on Mera glacier, Nepal, doing GPS measurements. Photo credit: Amaury Dehecq

Daniel Goldberg

In the field: co-author Daniel Goldberg (University of Edinburgh) in the Weddell Sea making sea ice measurements. Photo credit: Daniel Goldberg

Edward Hanna

In the field: co-author Edward Hanna (University of Sheffield) at the edge of Mittivakkat Gletscher, Greenland Ice Sheet Photo credit: Edward Hanna

Oct 28, 2015 • Ice sheets are in perpetual motion, making their way downslope like a river. If the amount of snow that an ice sheet accumulates does not keep pace with its loss to the sea, sea level will rise. As temperatures have climbed, positive feedback loops have led to an accelerated loss of ice sheet sections that touch the sea, but in an unexpected twist to the global warming saga, scientists have just discovered a negative feedback loop that is slowing down the Greenland Ice Sheet sections that end on land—a sliver of good news for sea-level rise.

This discovery will be published in Nature on Oct. 29, 2015. “Our latest results show that a large sector of the Greenland Ice Sheet which terminates on land has slowed down during the last decade—during a period of sustained warming. This suggests that further increases in melting will not cause these land-terminating margins of the ice sheet to speed up,” explained lead author Andrew Tedstone, a glaciologist at the University of Edinburgh.

Let’s step back and meet the Greenland Ice Sheet, an Alaska-sized block of ice that could raise sea levels by 23 feet (7 m) if it melted. Measuring the melt and motion of the ice sheet helps scientists understand how and when it will affect sea-level rise.

The overall mass of the Greenland Ice Sheet has been diminishing in recent decades as global temperatures rise, and 60 percent of this loss is due to surface melting. The amount of meltwater draining from the ice sheet in four out of the five years between 2007 and 2012 has been more substantial than anything in the last half-century. This meltwater makes it way to where the ice sheet meets the bedrock and there it may “grease the track” for the ice sheet to move faster seaward under its own weight.

This process has widely been thought to serve as a positive feedback between higher meltwater amount and faster ice sheet motion, but more recently a seasonality to this motion has been found. The larger meltwater volume of summertime leads to greater lubrication of the ice sheet base, speeding up its flow as expected. But by the time summer comes to a close, all that meltwater has established efficient drainage systems that lessen the water under the ice sheet (the “grease on the tracks”), slowing it down.

Until now, the long-term impact of this two-tempo ice sheet dance was unclear. Was there an overall speedup, slowdown, or just status quo?

To peer back in time, the team turned to Landsat. Using 475 image pairs from Landsats 5, 7, and 8 they analyzed ice sheet motion between 1985 and 2014 across an 8000 km2 land-terminating region of southwest Greenland.

“We would not have been able to complete this research without Landsat’s free and open data policy,” Noel Gourmelen, a co-author from the University of Edinburgh, explained. The open Landsat archive provided their team with the vast quantities of data they needed to make precise ice flow measurements on decadal scales.

“Landsat offers a unique continuous record of the surface of the Greenland Ice Sheet over the last 40 years, no other mission would have been able to provide observations of ice velocity change over such a long time period,” Gourmelen said.

By tracking stable features such as crevasses they established that there was a clear regional slowdown. This slowdown occurred despite a corresponding 50% increase in surface meltwater production.

This confirmed that there was a decadal slowdown of the land-terminating portions of the ice sheet, despite warming—a negative feedback loop was at work.

study area

The study area in southeastern Greenland. This Landsat image shows a land-terminating glacier. A closer view of the area in the red rectangle can be seen below. Image credit: USGS/NASA Landsat, processing by Matt Radcliff

close-up of study area land-terminating glacier

A land-terminating glacier in the study area; notice the thin margin of land between the glacier tongue and the water. Image credit: USGS/NASA Landsat; image processing by Matt Radcliff

Their next question was: what was the cause of this negative feedback loop? There were two potential explanations: ice sheet thinning (a symptom of the higher melting) or the meltwater-caused changes to the lubrication at the ice sheet’s base.

The team found that both processes were at work, but a much stronger input was coming from the reduced lubrication at the ice sheet base because of better meltwater drainage after summer. Their Landsat-based measurements have now established that the 50% increase in surface melt production on the Greenland Ice Sheet during the last decade has not sped up the motion of its land-terminating sections, but rather led to a slowdown. More research is needed to determine if this slowdown will continue as global warming continues to up meltwater.

“While these results may be viewed as a modicum of good news for the Greenland Ice Sheet, the ongoing acceleration of both glacier surface melt-volumes and ice-motion of ocean-terminating glaciers ensures that its contribution to sea level rise will likely increase in our warming world,” caveated paper co-author Peter Nienow.

“It is unclear how much more slowdown we will see under the current and future melting conditions—more research and observation are needed to determine this,” said Gourmelen. “The Landsat archive holds great potential for studying the processes behind the Greenland Ice Sheet’s response to our changing climate over multi-decadal time scales. It is essential that this record be exploited over other areas of the Greenland Ice Sheet.”

Elements of the Greenland ice sheet hydrologic system for land-terminating and marine-terminating glacier outlets.

Schematic illustrating the difference between land- and marine-terminating glaciers; sub-glacial channels that transport surface meltwater to the glacier’s base are also shown. Image credit: Vena Chu.

The University of Edinburgh is a charitable body, registered in Scotland, with registration number SC005336.

Andrew J. Tedstone, Peter W. Nienow, Noel Gourmelen, Amaury Dehecq, Daniel Goldberg, Edward Hanna (2015). "Decadal slowdown of a land-terminating sector of the Greenland Ice Sheet despite warming.", Nature, pp. 692–695 DOI: doi:10.1038/nature15722

Science brief by Laura E.P. Rocchio, NASA Landsat Communication & Public Outreach team

Further Reading:
+ Land-Facing, Southwest Greenland Ice Sheet Movement Decreasing, NASA
+ Slowdown of the Southwest Greenland Ice Sheet, NASA Earth Observatory
+ Greenland’s Ice Sheet Today, National Snow and Ice Data Center
+ Quick Facts on Ice Sheets, National Snow and Ice Data Center
+ Greenland Ice Sheet Hydrology, Vena W. Chu